Eye Liner
Cleaner pick · Safest multi-function eyes we have rated
Pacifica
Natural Minerals Dreambig Lash Extending 7 in 1 Mascara, Black Magic (2019 formulation)+37 on ingredient safety
$12–30
Ingredient safetyRaters agree
Ranked by safety only. Greenlens earns from qualifying purchases. Payout never affects a rating, a ranking, or the cleaner pick.
Raters split
Ingredient safety
A 49-point gap between the two loudest voices.
45ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment
vs94Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent
050100
See why, ingredient by ingredientAll 56 cleaner options, safest first We show the best 12, including the strongest on each axis.
Every rater, every axis
Ingredient safety
49 pts apartIndependent — not funded by the brands it rates. Auto-linked to this product, not yet human-reviewed. Checked this week. about this rater →
Independent — not funded by the brands it rates. Auto-linked to this product, not yet human-reviewed. Checked this week. about this rater →
Independent — not funded by the brands it rates. Auto-linked to this product, not yet human-reviewed. Checked this week. about this rater →
A government authority. Auto-linked to this product, not yet human-reviewed. Checked this week. about this rater →
A government authority. Auto-linked to this product, not yet human-reviewed. Checked this week. about this rater →
Also screened, nothing found: Health Canada Ingredient Hotlist · US NTP Report on Carcinogens · ECHA SVHC Candidate List · California Proposition 65 · EU Harmonised Classification (CLP Annex VI)
Environmental
Also screened, nothing found: EU Microplastics Restriction
Labor
Run by a nonprofit. Auto-linked to this product, not yet human-reviewed. This rates Maybelline as a company and applies to everything they make, not this product alone. Checked this week. about this rater →
Coverage & match quality
6 ratings · 2 of 4 axes
- Some ratings rest on an automatic match that has not been human-reviewed.
- Fewer raters reach smaller-brand products, so a missing rating is not a clean bill of health, only a gap.
Weighted by what you care about
Tune your weights
composite recomputes live
+
1.0×
Environmentalno rating
No rater covers this axis for this product, so its weight can't move the score.
1.0×
Packagingno rating
No rater covers this axis for this product, so its weight can't move the score.
0 means ignored. Higher = more weight in your composite.
Ingredients, decoded
Data availability
Robust31 of 31 characterized
Our sources have reference data on all 31 listed ingredients.
Worth a look (3)
ANSES CMR-listedflagged by 5 of 9 lists →
ANSES endocrine candidateflagged by 1 of 9 lists →
Mild sensitizer for someflagged by 1 of 9 lists →
No flags in our sources (28)
- Aqua/Water/Eau
- Styrene/Acrylates/Ammonium Methacrylate Copolymer
- Propylene Glycolcommon irritant
- Polyester-5
- Polysorbate 80
- Butylene Glycol
- PPG-2 Butyl Ether
- Caprylyl Glycol
- Sodium Laureth Sulfate
- Xanthan Gum
- Sodium Dehydroacetate
- Disodium EDTA
- Tetrasodium EDTA
- Calcium Aluminum Borosilicate
- Potassium Sorbate
- Synthetic Fluorphlogopite
- Silica
- May Contain CI 77491
- CI 77492
- CI 77499/Iron Oxides
- CI 77007/Ultramarines
- Mica
- CI 75470/Carmine
- CI 77288/Chromium Oxide Greens
- CI 77289/Chromium Hydroxide Green
- CI 77742/Manganese Violet
- CI 77510/Ferric Ammonium Ferrocyanide
- CI 77510/Ferric Ferrocyanide
What these ingredient tags mean (2)
These describe what an ingredient is, not whether it is a problem. The stance marks above are the ratings; these are not.
commonly dryingAlcohol Denat
- Alcohol Denat: Denatured ethanol: a fast-evaporating solvent that thins a formula and leaves a dry finish. International Chemical Safety Card ICSC 0044, Ethanol (anhydrous), prepared by an international group of experts for the ILO and WHO: "The substance defats the skin, which may cause dryness or cracking." WHO Guidelines on Hand Hygiene in Health Care (2009) records depletion of the skin lipid barrier by lipid-dissolving alcohols, and also that "the lipid-dissolving effect of alcohols is inversely related to their concentration". Both describe stronger exposures than a cosmetic formula.
common irritantPropylene Glycol
- Propylene Glycol: A solvent that shows up in patch-test clinics, more often as irritation than as allergy. American Contact Dermatitis Society, Allergen of the Year 2018 (Jacob SE, Scheman A, McGowan MA, Dermatitis 2018;29(1):3-5).