Browse In your home Methodology Ask Sonion

Greenlens

Navigate

Browse
In your home
Ask Sonion
Methodology
Criteria
Extension
How scoring works
Account

Cosmetics only · lead with safetyProduct data from public sources incl. Open Beauty Facts & EWG Skin Deep · their ratings never scraped or shown

As an Amazon Associate, Greenlens earns from qualifying purchases. Affiliate income never changes a rating or ranking.Privacy Terms

e.l.f. — every product, every rater | Greenlens

Catalog/e.l.f.

e.l.f.

802 products in the catalog · elfcosmetics.com (visit site, opens in a new tab)

70Fair
avg. across 798 rated products · one axis, not the card composite: 676
products the raters split on

The average covers the ingredient-safety axis only, computed live from each product's raters — never a blended or stored brand score. Open a product to weight the axes yourself.

All products Blush 53 Concealer 102 Eye Cream 4 Foundation 61 Lip Balm 44 Lip Gloss 70 Lip Liner 14 Lipstick 22 Makeup Remover 4 Mascara 14 Primer 42 Sunscreen 5

Sort

Best overall Worst overall Most contested A–Z

95
e.l.f.
Lash It Loud Mascara
ExcellentOverall · your weights
9990
Data Robust · 19/20
5 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Labor
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Lash It Loud Volumizing Mascara

e.l.f.

Lash It Loud Volumizing Mascara

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9990

Data Robust · 18/20

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Studio Length & Volume Mascara, 81401 Black (2019 formulation)

e.l.f.

Studio Length & Volume Mascara, 81401 Black (2019 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9990

Data Robust · 18/19

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Cosmetics Lash It Loud Mascara, Black

e.l.f.

Cosmetics Lash It Loud Mascara, Black

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9990

Data Robust · 18/19

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Studio Lengthening & Volumizing Mascara, Waterproof, Black (2020 formulation)

e.l.f.

Studio Lengthening & Volumizing Mascara, Waterproof, Black (2020 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

998690

Data Robust · 18/20

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Environmental

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment86
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Big Mood Mega Volume & Lifting Mascara, Black

e.l.f.

Big Mood Mega Volume & Lifting Mascara, Black

ExcellentOverall · your weights

998690

Data Robust · 17/18

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Environmental

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment86
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92

Waterproof Length & Volume Mascara, Black

e.l.f.

Waterproof Length & Volume Mascara, Black

ExcellentOverall · your weights

958690

Data Robust · 21/21

7 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Environmental

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment86
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Cosmetics Liquid Lash Xtnder Mascara, Pitch Black

e.l.f.

Cosmetics Liquid Lash Xtnder Mascara, Pitch Black

ExcellentOverall · your weights

888690

raters split 80–100

Data Robust · 20/21

7 raters · split 80–100 on ingredient safety

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment80
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment86
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

e.l.f.

Jet Black Volumizing & Defining Mascara (2019 formulation)

GoodOverall · your weights

768690

raters split 65–98

Data Robust · 23/24

7 raters · split 65–98 on ingredient safety

ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment65
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment86
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Clear Brow & Lash Mascara, Clear (2019 formulation)

e.l.f.

Clear Brow & Lash Mascara, Clear (2019 formulation)

GoodOverall · your weights

7692

raters split 65–98

Data Robust · 8/8

5 raters · split 65–98 on ingredient safety

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment65
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92

e.l.f.

Cosmetics Volumizing Mascara

GoodOverall · your weights

768690

raters split 65–98

Data Robust · 21/22

7 raters · split 65–98 on ingredient safety

ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment65
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment86
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Mineral Infused Mascara, Black (2019 formulation)

e.l.f.

Mineral Infused Mascara, Black (2019 formulation)

GoodOverall · your weights

768690

raters split 65–98

Data Robust · 18/19

7 raters · split 65–98 on ingredient safety

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment65
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment86
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92

Defining & Volumizing Mascara, Black (2020 formulation)

e.l.f.

Defining & Volumizing Mascara, Black (2020 formulation)

GoodOverall · your weights

747890

raters split 65–93

Data Robust · 24/27

8 raters · split 65–93 on ingredient safety

Health Canada Ingredient HotlistGovernment85
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent93
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent88
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent80
IARC MonographsGovernment65
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment78
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Eye Enhancing Mascara (2019 formulation)

e.l.f.

Eye Enhancing Mascara (2019 formulation)

GoodOverall · your weights

528690

raters split 30–93

Data Robust · 24/25

8 raters · split 30–93 on ingredient safety

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent93
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent88
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment30
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent80
IARC MonographsGovernment82
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment86
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit92
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88