14 products in the catalog
Ingredient safety
The average covers the ingredient-safety axis only, computed live from each product's raters — never a blended or stored brand score. Open a product to weight the axes yourself.

Bys
Metal Lips Creme Lipstick 24K Gold (2018 formulation)
9485
Data Robust · 12/13
4 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Labor

Bys
Metal Lips Creme Lipstick, 05 Bronzed Medal (2018 formulation)
9485
Data Robust · 12/13
4 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Labor

Bys
Lips Liquid Lipstick, 03 Flamingo Flare Velvet (2018 formulation)
3685
raters split 15–95
Data Robust · 11/12
6 raters · split 15–95 on ingredient safety

Bys
Velvet Lips Liquid Lipstick, 07 Prima Peonies (2018 formulation)
3085
raters split 10–82
Data Robust · 11/12
8 raters · split 10–82 on ingredient safety

Bys
Velvet Lips Liquid Lipstick, 12 Purple Pop (2018 formulation)
3085
raters split 10–82
Data Robust · 11/12
8 raters · split 10–82 on ingredient safety