348 products in the catalog
Ingredient safety
The average covers the ingredient-safety axis only, computed live from each product's raters — never a blended or stored brand score. Open a product to weight the axes yourself.

Flower
Beauty LIQUID KAJAL BLENDABLE EYELINER, Spiced
7586
raters split 65–94
Data Robust · 14/15
6 raters · split 65–94 on ingredient safety
Flower
Beauty LIQUID KAJAL BLENDABLE EYELINER, Smoldering
7586
raters split 65–94
Data Robust · 15/16
6 raters · split 65–94 on ingredient safety
Flower
Beauty LIQUID KAJAL BLENDABLE EYELINER, Jaded
7586
raters split 65–94
Data Robust · 15/16
6 raters · split 65–94 on ingredient safety
Flower
Beauty LIQUID KAJAL BLENDABLE EYELINER, Starry
7586
raters split 65–94
Data Robust · 18/19
6 raters · split 65–94 on ingredient safety
Flower
Beauty LIQUID KAJAL BLENDABLE EYELINER, Rust
7586
raters split 65–94
Data Robust · 14/15
6 raters · split 65–94 on ingredient safety
Flower
Beauty Forever Wear Eye-Lighter
7578
raters split 65–95
Data Robust · 12/12
6 raters · split 65–95 on ingredient safety

Flower
Forever Wear Longwear Eyeliner, Forever Amethyst (2019 formulation)
75
Data Robust · 29/31
6 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Ingredient safety
Flower
Forever Wear Longwear Eyeliner, Forever Sapphire (2019 formulation)
75
Data Robust · 29/31
6 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Ingredient safety
Flower
Forever Wear Longwear Eyeliner, Forever Emerald (2019 formulation)
75
Data Robust · 29/31
6 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Ingredient safety
Flower
Beauty Forever Wear Longwear Eyeliner, Forever Emerald
72
raters split 65–94
Data Robust · 24/26
6 raters · split 65–94 on ingredient safety
Flower
Beauty Forever Wear Longwear Eyeliner, Forever Brownstone
71
raters split 65–88
Data Good · 28/33
6 raters · split 65–88 on ingredient safety
Flower
Beauty Forever Wear Longwear Eyeliner, Forever Amethyst
71
raters split 65–88
Data Robust · 26/30
6 raters · split 65–88 on ingredient safety

Flower
Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel Eyeliner, Galaxy (2019 formulation)
6078
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 29/30
8 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety
Flower
Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel Eyeliner, Purple Quartz (2019 formulation)
6078
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 29/30
8 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety
Flower
Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel Eyeliner, Serpent (2019 formulation)
6078
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 29/30
8 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety
Flower
Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel Eyeliner, Silver Fox (2019 formulation)
6078
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 29/30
8 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety
Flower
Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel Eyeliner, Bronzed Out (2019 formulation)
6078
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 29/30
8 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety
Flower
Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel Eyeliner, Starry Night (2019 formulation)
6078
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 29/30
8 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety
Flower
Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel Eyeliner, Black Vinyl (2019 formulation)
6078
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 29/30
8 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety
Flower
Style Eyes Liquid Eyeliner, Espresso Ink (2019 formulation)
51
raters split 30–93
Data Robust · 21/22
5 raters · split 30–93 on ingredient safety
Flower
Style Eyes Liquid Eyeliner, Onyx (2019 formulation)
51
raters split 30–93
Data Robust · 21/22
5 raters · split 30–93 on ingredient safety