Browse In your home Methodology Ask Sonion

Greenlens

Every public rating on one cosmetic, the places they disagree kept visible, and a single score whose weighting you control.

Navigate

Browse
In your home
Ask Sonion
Methodology
Criteria
Extension
How scoring works
Account

The one rule

We never blend a score that hides who disagrees. Funding model travels with every rating. Weights are computed at read time and never stored.

Cosmetics only · lead with safetyProduct data from public sources incl. Open Beauty Facts & EWG Skin Deep · their ratings never scraped or shown

As an Amazon Associate, Greenlens earns from qualifying purchases. Affiliate income never changes a rating or ranking.Privacy Terms

Physicians Formula — every product, every rater | Greenlens

Catalog/Physicians Formula

Physicians Formula

358 products in the catalog

55Fair
avg. across 349 rated products · one axis, not the card composite: 326
products the raters split on

The average covers the ingredient-safety axis only, computed live from each product's raters — never a blended or stored brand score. Open a product to weight the axes yourself.

All products Blush 29 Bronzer Highlighter 71 Concealer 23 Foundation 13 Lip Balm 12 Lip Gloss 13 Lipstick 14 Makeup Eyes 40 Makeup Face 46 Makeup Lips 30 Mascara 13 Primer 6

Sort

Best overall Worst overall Most contested A–Z

93
Physicians Formula
24 Karat Gold Collagen Lip Serum
ExcellentOverall · your weights
10087
Data Robust · 16/16
5 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Labor
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

← PreviousPage 1 of 15Next →

Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover (2020 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover (2020 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

10087

Data Robust · 16/16

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

Organic Wear Organic Wear, Lash Boosting Mascara, 7562 Black (2019 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Organic Wear Organic Wear, Lash Boosting Mascara, 7562 Black (2019 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

10087

Data Robust · 18/19

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Organic Wear Bright Booster Oil Elixir (2020 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Organic Wear Bright Booster Oil Elixir (2020 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

10087

Data Robust · 9/9

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

The Breakfast Club Detention Mascara, Ruckus Black Noir

Physicians Formula

The Breakfast Club Detention Mascara, Ruckus Black Noir

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9987

Data Robust · 27/27

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Face Primer (2020 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Face Primer (2020 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9987

Data Robust · 14/14

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Mineral Wear Diamond Gloss - Crystal Clear

Physicians Formula

Mineral Wear Diamond Gloss - Crystal Clear

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9987

Data Robust · 9/9

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

All-Star Face Palette

Physicians Formula

All-Star Face Palette

ExcellentOverall · your weights

10085

Data Robust · 10/10

4 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

24-Karat Gold Skin-Rejuvenating Collagen Oil, Anti-Aging, 24-Karat Gold

Physicians Formula

24-Karat Gold Skin-Rejuvenating Collagen Oil, Anti-Aging, 24-Karat Gold

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9985

Data Robust · 12/12

4 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

Organic Wear Natural Origin Mascara, Black (2019 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Organic Wear Natural Origin Mascara, Black (2019 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9687

Data Robust · 21/22

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Natural Origin Mascara, 6885 Ultra Black (2019 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Natural Origin Mascara, 6885 Ultra Black (2019 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9687

Data Robust · 20/22

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Organic Wear Double Cleansing Oil

Physicians Formula

Organic Wear Double Cleansing Oil

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9587

Data Robust · 20/20

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Eye Booster Waterproof Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner, Pf10970 Blackest Black

Physicians Formula

Eye Booster Waterproof Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner, Pf10970 Blackest Black

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9587

Data Robust · 17/18

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

Lash Boosting Mascara, Black (2019 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Lash Boosting Mascara, Black (2019 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9287

Data Good · 26/31

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Mineral Wear Diamond 5 in 1 Clear Mascara, Clear Diamond 1711954

Physicians Formula

Mineral Wear Diamond 5 in 1 Clear Mascara, Clear Diamond 1711954

ExcellentOverall · your weights

919087

Data Robust · 19/20

7 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment80
EU Microplastics RestrictionGovernment90
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Lash-Boosting Volumisateur Mascara, Ultra Black

Physicians Formula

Lash-Boosting Volumisateur Mascara, Ultra Black

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9287

Data Robust · 27/29

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent100
IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Setting Spray (2020 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Setting Spray (2020 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

8987

Data Robust · 16/17

7 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment80
Health Canada Ingredient HotlistGovernment85
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Lifting & Glowing Mask, PF11054 Lift & Glow (2020 formulation)

Physicians Formula

Lifting & Glowing Mask, PF11054 Lift & Glow (2020 formulation)

ExcellentOverall · your weights

8987

Data Robust · 37/37

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent81
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit88

Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner | Deep Brown

Physicians Formula

Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner | Deep Brown

ExcellentOverall · your weights

8985

Data Robust · 23/23

6 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent90
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment80
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

Physicians Formula

Mineral Wear Lip Oil, Yellow Diamond

ExcellentOverall · your weights

9380

Data Robust · 20/21

5 raters · broadly agree

Weakest on Labor

Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent94
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent87
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85
Open Beauty Facts CertificationsNonprofit74

24 Karat Gold Collagen Eye Cream

Physicians Formula

24 Karat Gold Collagen Eye Cream

ExcellentOverall · your weights

8785

raters split 80–100

Data Robust · 27/27

5 raters · split 80–100 on ingredient safety

Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment80
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

Organic Wear Brow Shaping Gel With Jojoba Oil, Clear Transparent Pf11080

Physicians Formula

Organic Wear Brow Shaping Gel With Jojoba Oil, Clear Transparent Pf11080

ExcellentOverall · your weights

8685

raters split 80–100

Data Robust · 20/20

6 raters · split 80–100 on ingredient safety

IARC MonographsGovernment82
Greenlens Precautionary ScreenIndependent98
ANSES Endocrine DisruptorsGovernment80
Greenlens Ingredient ScanIndependent100
Greenlens Tolerance ScreenIndependent100
Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

Super BB All-in-1 Beauty Balm Powder

Physicians Formula

Super BB All-in-1 Beauty Balm Powder

ExcellentLabor only

85

1 rater so far

Weakest on Labor

Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85

Mineral Wear Talc-Free Mineral Airbrushing Pressed Powder | Translucent

Physicians Formula

Mineral Wear Talc-Free Mineral Airbrushing Pressed Powder | Translucent

ExcellentLabor only

85

1 rater so far

Weakest on Labor

Cruelty-Free CertificationNonprofit85