140 products in the catalog
Ingredient safety
The average covers the ingredient-safety axis only, computed live from each product's raters — never a blended or stored brand score. Open a product to weight the axes yourself.

Sugar
Cosmetics Stroke Of Genius Heavy-Duty Kohl, 02 Purple Rain
96
Data Robust · 14/14
4 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Ingredient safety

Sugar
Cosmetics Stroke Of Genius Heavy-Duty Kohl, 01 Back to Black
96
Data Robust · 14/14
4 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Ingredient safety

Sugar
Cosmetics Stroke Of Genius Heavy-Duty Kohl, 04 Blue Suede Shoes
96
Data Robust · 14/14
4 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Wingman Waterproof Microliner, 01 I'll Be Black
95
Data Robust · 19/20
4 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Arch Arrival Brow Styler
10086
Data Robust · 5/5
4 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Environmental
Sugar
Cosmetics Blacklash Volumizing Mascara, 01 Black Up
91
Data Robust · 23/23
4 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Ingredient safety

Sugar
Cosmetics Eye Warned You So! Double Matte Eyeliner, 01 Black Swan
9178
Data Robust · 17/17
5 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Environmental

Sugar
Cosmetics Eye Warned You So! Double Matte Eyeliner, 04 Coffee Shop
9178
Data Robust · 17/17
5 raters · broadly agree
Weakest on Environmental
Sugar
Cosmetics Bold Unfold Waterproof Mascara, 02 Star Sapphire
76
raters split 65–98
Data Robust · 14/16
4 raters · split 65–98 on ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Lash Mob Limitless Mascara
76
raters split 65–98
Data Robust · 20/20
4 raters · split 65–98 on ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Blend The Rules Eyeshadow Palette, 08 Reflection
7378
raters split 65–93
Data Robust · 18/18
8 raters · split 65–93 on ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Lash Of The Titans Volumizing Mascara, 01 Black with a Bang
75
raters split 65–98
Data Robust · 19/22
5 raters · split 65–98 on ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Arch Arrival Micro Brow Pencil, 02 Taupe Tom
75
raters split 65–95
Data Robust · 18/18
5 raters · split 65–95 on ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Arch Arrival Micro Brow Pencil, 01 Jerry Brown
75
raters split 65–95
Data Robust · 18/18
5 raters · split 65–95 on ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Blend The Rules Eyeshadow Palette, 04 Fetish
6034
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 21/21
7 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety
Sugar
Cosmetics Blend The Rules Eyeshadow Palette, 03 Fantasy
6034
raters split 47–88
Data Robust · 21/21
7 raters · split 47–88 on ingredient safety